Recurring Nightmares

The Recurring Nightmare Of Eva P

By: Mikh | 13/08/2025

The Endless Night: The Recurring Nightmare of Eva P., an Auschwitz Survivor

Nightmares are a universal human experience, but recurring nightmares—dreams that repeat with disturbing similarity over months, years, or even decades—stand apart as one of the most haunting manifestations of human memory and trauma. Among the many documented cases of recurring nightmares, few are as harrowing and historically significant as that of Eva P., a survivor of Auschwitz whose dreams became an unbroken link to the horrors of the Holocaust.

Historical Background: The Holocaust and Psychological Scars

Between 1940 and 1945, Auschwitz was the largest of the Nazi concentration and extermination camps, where more than 1.1 million men, women, and children were murdered. For those who survived, liberation did not mark an end to suffering. The trauma of starvation, torture, forced labor, and the ever-present threat of death often resurfaced in their subconscious minds. Nightmares became a cruel echo of reality—a way in which the body and mind refused to let go of horror.

Psychologist and Holocaust survivor Dr. Charlotte Beradt was among the first to systematically collect and study these dreams. In her research, she found that many survivors described identical recurring nightmares: scenes of roll calls, barbed wire, selections for the gas chambers, and the loss of family members. Among these testimonies, the case of Eva P. stood out for its intensity, consistency, and longevity.

Eva P.’s Recurring Nightmare

After surviving Auschwitz and emigrating to the United States, Eva P. hoped to start anew. She married, had children, and built a seemingly ordinary life. Yet, every night, when the world quieted and she closed her eyes, the past would return.

In her nightmare, Eva was back at the gates of Auschwitz. She described hearing the clang of iron doors and the rhythmic boots of SS guards striking the pavement. The dream never changed: she was standing in a line of prisoners, surrounded by fear and silence. Ahead of her, a guard called out numbers, pointing left or right. One direction meant life through forced labor; the other meant death in the gas chambers. No matter how the dream began, it always ended the same way—Eva being torn away from her family, pushed toward the chamber doors, unable to scream or resist.

For Eva, the dream carried two unbearable truths: the terror of being helpless and the guilt of survival. She survived Auschwitz while so many of her family and friends did not. Her subconscious trapped her in an eternal replay of the moment when survival was decided by arbitrary cruelty.

The Longevity of the Nightmare

What makes Eva’s case remarkable is its duration. Survivors often reported recurring nightmares in the immediate years following the war, but for Eva, the nightmare persisted for decades. Well into her old age, she still experienced the same haunting sequence. Sometimes stress, loud noises, or the sound of boots on hard floors triggered the nightmare with greater intensity.

Unlike ordinary bad dreams that fade with time or therapy, Eva’s recurring nightmare behaved more like a psychological scar—a permanent wound etched into her memory. Researchers have since identified this phenomenon as a form of chronic post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), where the subconscious mind refuses to process trauma as "past" and instead relives it as if it were happening in the present.

Psychological Analysis: Trauma Encoded in the Subconscious

Eva’s recurring nightmare illustrates how trauma embeds itself into the psyche. In psychology, recurring nightmares are often linked to unfinished emotional processing. When an event is too overwhelming for the brain to fully process—such as war, torture, or mass atrocity—the subconscious may “replay” it in the form of dreams, attempting to resolve what the conscious mind cannot.

For Holocaust survivors, the trauma was not just physical but existential: the systematic attempt to erase their very identity. Nightmares like Eva’s symbolized not only fear of death but also fear of obliteration. Modern neuroscience supports this interpretation, showing that extreme trauma can alter the functioning of the amygdala and hippocampus, the brain regions that regulate fear and memory.

In Eva’s case, her nightmare functioned as both a symptom and a memorial. It was a symptom of her psychological wound, but also a way her subconscious forced her never to forget, ensuring that the memory of Auschwitz remained alive inside her, even as the world around her moved forward.

Broader Implications: Nightmares as Historical Witness

Eva’s recurring nightmare is not merely a personal story—it is part of a collective testimony. Survivors like her carried memories that official history books could never fully capture. While documents and photographs record facts, nightmares reveal the emotional truth of trauma: the fear, helplessness, and despair that statistics cannot convey.

Dr. Beradt argued that these dreams served as “private documents of history.” Eva’s nightmare, replayed thousands of times over her life, was as much a historical record as any diary entry or survivor testimony. It revealed that the Holocaust did not end in 1945—it continued to live in the subconscious of those who endured it.

Conclusion: The Endless Night

The story of Eva P. demonstrates that recurring nightmares are not just medical curiosities, but profound windows into the human condition. For her, sleep was never a refuge. Instead, every night she returned to Auschwitz, reliving terror in a loop that time could not break. Her nightmare was both a burden and a form of remembrance, ensuring that the crimes of history were never erased, even in silence.

Eva’s story reminds us of the resilience and fragility of the human mind. It shows how trauma lives on in ways we cannot always control, and how dreams—far from being mere illusions—can become the truest record of suffering. Through her recurring nightmare, Eva bore witness not only to her own pain but also to the enduring shadow of the Holocaust, carried into the most private corners of human consciousness.

Coming Soon

We're on a mission ......................................